Muncie spends Wednesday afternoon at Minnetrista hearing the story of Cyrus Dallin's two downtown statues, The Passing of the Buffalo among them, and Wednesday night a Buffalo team shows up with no plans to go quietly. My Buffalo vs Ball State spread pick is Buffalo Bulls −1.5 with the Over 50.5, and the final reads Buffalo Bulls 28, Ball State Cardinals 25 at Scheumann Stadium, 7:30 PM ET.
Kendra Woolcott has heard that statue title all day. "We've won four in a row, Gus. Chance Morrow caught 12 balls for 199 yards and two scores at Miami. Messiah Burch has 901 yards. Nobody's passing anything but the ball tonight."
Gus Ponder answers with a dad joke and then the facts. "Why did the Bull cross the Indiana state line? To lose by a field goal. TJ Horton has 9 rushing touchdowns on 72 carries, Keldric Luster has 10 touchdown throws, and we lost at UMass by one in overtime. Jalen Bonds ran for 132 that night. We are closer than the record."
The number moved, so I went back through the whole game. DraftKings opened Buffalo −3 and it has slid all the way to 1.5. My football did not move. Buffalo has been living on the wire for a month and finishing: 25-18 in overtime over Massachusetts, 31-24 over Bowling Green and 34-31 in overtime at Miami. Ball State plays the same kind of game, 32-31 in overtime at Bowling Green and that 31-30 overtime loss at UMass. The Bulls are 6-3, 4-1 in the MAC and second in the conference, and I have them winning by a field goal. At 1.5 that clears, so I'm laying it with Buffalo.
Both quarterback spots are settled. Jason Wright has taken the most throws in eight straight Buffalo games, and he threw 46 times for 358 yards at Miami. Luster has done it in eight of Ball State's nine. Wright's 9 touchdowns and 6 interceptions on 231 attempts say Buffalo wins on volume, not precision.
On the over/under, DraftKings opened at 51.5 and it has dipped to 50.5, so I'm getting a point of help on the Over 50.5. Ball State allows 34.8 a game. The last meeting, in 2024, finished Buffalo 51, Ball State 48. Morrow has 8 touchdown catches. My 28-25 lands on 53.
Opinions in the room run every direction. Next Man Up has it 29-29, takes Ball State Cardinals +1.5 and likes the Over 50.5. In The Trenches flips my score to Ball State 28-25, likes the Cardinals +1.5 and makes no over/under call. The Formula has Buffalo 28-24, lays the −1.5 and goes Over. Letdown Watch has Buffalo 29-21, likes the Bulls −2.5 and takes the Under. Follow The Money likes Ball State Cardinals +1.5 and has no total pick.
Letdown Watch: "Four straight wins for Buffalo, Next Man Up, and you still can't name a winner."
Next Man Up: "Two of those four went to overtime, Letdown Watch. That's not finding a way. That's borrowing one."
Kendra changes into shorts, November in Indiana or not, because she plans to celebrate. Gus tells her the Campus Orchestra is playing Sursa Hall at kickoff and offers to have them play her something slow on the way out.
Buffalo Bulls 28, Ball State Cardinals 25. Buffalo Bulls cover the 1.5. Over 50.5.