The Cover Window
Games / College / Nov 11, 2026 / Buffalo Bulls at Ball State Cardinals · Fanatic

The Fanatic · College

Buffalo vs Ball State: Tea, Dallin's Statues and a Muncie Fight

Buffalo Bulls (6-3) at Ball State Cardinals (3-6)

7:30 PM ET Wed Nov 11 · Scheumann Stadium · ESPN2

XFacebook

Muncie spends Wednesday afternoon with a cup of tea and a piece of its own history. Buffalo Bulls vs Ball State Cardinals kicks off at Scheumann Stadium that night, but first, over at Minnetrista, local historian Karen Vincent tells the story of Cyrus Dallin's two famous downtown statues, The Passing of the Buffalo and Appeal to the Great Spirit, and Gus Ponder has had his ticket for weeks.

"You have to go," Gus tells Kendra Woolcott. "Three o'clock, the Indiana Room, refreshments included. You learn something, you eat a cookie, you come to the game smarter. That's a Wednesday."

Kendra came in from Western New York with a coat she doesn't plan to wear and a team that hasn't lost in a month. "I'll go," she says. "But I want it on record that I'm only there for the history."

The history is worth it. Dallin made The Passing of the Buffalo in 1929, a Native American chief in full regalia with a bow in his hand and his foot resting on a buffalo skull. It stood first on an estate in New Jersey, came to Muncie in 1975 and was dedicated to the city on April 25, 1976. When construction pushed it off its corner in 1999, it was restored and kept safe in the Minnetrista lobby until September 26, 2007, when it went back up on its original boulder in the roundabout at Walnut and Seymour Streets.

"That's a town that takes care of what it loves," Kendra says, and she means it.

"Now you understand Muncie," Gus says. "Now let me tell you about my football team."

Ball State is 3-6 and 2-3 in the MAC, and Gus is the first to admit the defense has had a rough fall. The Cardinals have given up 34.8 points a game. But look at the last three weeks. Ball State beat Bowling Green 32-31 in overtime, beat Sacramento State 34-17 at Homecoming and lost at UMass last Wednesday 31-30, also in overtime.

"One point," Gus says. "One point at UMass. You know what they call a team that loses by one in overtime? Next week's problem."

Keldric Luster has thrown for 1,482 yards and 10 touchdowns, and he's taken the most throws in eight of the nine games. TJ Horton has 9 rushing touchdowns on just 72 carries, which Gus says is the most efficient thing in Delaware County since the roundabout. Jalen Bonds ran 17 times for 132 yards and 2 scores at UMass. Donovan Hamilton leads the receivers with 354 yards. On defense, Sterling Smith has 46 tackles from the secondary and Ben Marsh has 3 sacks.

Kendra lets him finish, then slides over her own list. Buffalo is 6-3, 4-1 in the MAC and second in the conference. The Bulls have won four straight: 23-8 at Toledo, 25-18 in overtime over Massachusetts, 31-24 over Bowling Green and 34-31 in overtime at Miami last Tuesday.

"We play close, too," Kendra says. "We just finish."

Messiah Burch carries the load, 165 times for 901 yards. Chance Morrow is the one Jason Wright trusts most, with 53 catches for 679 yards and 8 touchdowns, and at Miami he caught 12 for 199 yards and two scores. Wright threw it 46 times that night for 358 yards. SaVeon Brown has 75 tackles at linebacker, and Will Clark has 3.5 sacks.

"Twelve catches," Gus says, shaking his head. "That's not a receiver. That's a subscription."

"He renews every week," Kendra says.

The recent history between these two is a coin toss. Since 2016, Ball State has won three of the five meetings and Buffalo has won two. The last one, in 2024, was absolute madness: Buffalo 51, Ball State 48. Gus remembers every snap. Kendra remembers every snap and the score of every snap.

"Ninety-nine points," Gus says. "My producer at the station still brings it up."

"Your station called it a classic," Kendra says. "I called it Tuesday."

Across campus, the Ball State Campus Orchestra plays a free concert at Sursa Performance Hall at 7:30, the same minute the ball goes up in the air at Scheumann. Gus says he'll catch the encore on the replay. Kendra says the real symphony is a Buffalo drive that takes six minutes off the clock.

So here's the Wednesday script. Ball State comes out loose and fast, and Horton punches in an early score to wake up the student section. Buffalo answers through the air, because Wright keeps finding Morrow in the soft spots. It's tied at the half, and it stays tight all the way into the fourth. Bonds and Horton keep Ball State in it. Then Burch finally breaks one, Brown makes a big stop, and the Bulls kick a late field goal to escape Muncie by three.

Kendra changes into shorts in the parking lot, November or not. Gus packs up his notes, laughs at his own joke one more time and says next week's problem is now Buffalo's problem.

Muncie loses a heartbreaker. Gus laughs the whole way out of the parking lot.

My call: Buffalo Bulls 28, Ball State Cardinals 25.

XFacebook
Open this week in the live app → More from Nov 14, 2026