Part 1: Handicap Recap
Cowboys 38, Eagles 21
The first quarter was a track meet, which the Over loved. Brandon Aubrey opened it with a 55-yard field goal. Quinnen Williams jumped offside with a neutral zone infraction, and on the next snap Saquon Barkley ran 8 yards for a touchdown. Dak Prescott hit CeeDee Lamb for 9 yards and a 10-7 lead. Then another Dallas flag broke the Eagles' way. On 4th-and-1 at the Philadelphia 44, Tanner McKee fumbled the snap and Williams recovered it, and Williams' own offside flag erased the whole play. Later in the drive, on 3rd-and-7 at the Dallas 9, LT Overton was flagged for roughing the passer on an incompletion. Dameon Pierce scored from 5 yards on the next snap. Eagles 14-10, and the Eagles +4.5 was covering by 8.5.
Then came the flag that saved every Eagles ticket in the second quarter. Tyler Goodson took the ensuing kickoff 91 yards for a touchdown, and a holding flag on Dallas' Justin Barron brought it all back. Instead of a Dallas lead, it was still Eagles 14-10. Dallas then went 81 yards in 14 plays anyway, converting a 4th-and-1 at the Philadelphia 44 on a Javonte Williams run, and Prescott hit George Pickens for a 21-yard touchdown. Before the half, Prescott found Lamb for 30 yards down to the Philadelphia 9 with 19 seconds left. Two incompletions later Aubrey kicked a 27-yarder on the final play of the half. Halftime: Cowboys 20, Eagles 14. The Eagles +4.5 was losing by 1.5, and the Over had 34 and needed 11 more.
The third quarter opened with the drive Eagles bettors will tell their grandkids about: 17 plays, 84 yards and 9:16 off the clock. McKee converted a 4th-and-1 at the Dallas 39 with a 15-yard pass to Makai Lemon. Then, on 3rd-and-goal from the 4, he hit Lemon for the touchdown. Eagles 21-20. The Eagles +4.5 was covering by 5.5, and the Over had 41 and needed four.
Here is the swing of the night. Dallas faced 2nd-and-1 at the Philadelphia 18 with 2:17 left in the third. Prescott lost the ball, and Riq Woolen scooped it up and ran 73 yards for a touchdown. Replay called it an incomplete forward pass and took the whole thing back. That would have put the Eagles up 27-20 before the extra point, with the Eagles +4.5 covering by 11.5. Instead, two snaps later, Prescott hit Lamb for a 16-yard touchdown and then ran in the two-point conversion himself. Cowboys 28-21. The Over cashed right there, with 49 points and more than a quarter to play. The side was still alive, because one Eagles field goal would have put them inside the 4.5.
The fourth quarter took that away, and it started with a flag. Cooper DeJean was called for a 17-yard pass interference on the first snap of the next Dallas drive, Javonte Williams ripped off 34 yards two plays later, and Aubrey made a 24-yarder on 4th-and-5 for a 31-21 lead. Now the Eagles +4.5 needed a touchdown. Philadelphia got to the Dallas 32, and DeMarvion Overshown intercepted McKee at the 30 with 7:55 left. Philadelphia got one more look after a Dallas delay of game on 4th-and-1 forced a punt. Quinnen Williams sacked McKee for a loss of 8, and McKee's 4th-and-9 throw to Hollywood Brown fell incomplete. Javonte Williams finished it with a 2-yard touchdown at 2:21. He ran 25 times for 155 yards. Cowboys 38-21.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
Patriots 24, Bears 30
The Patriots +3 and the Under 50.5 were both alive at 27-21 with eight minutes left, when Cairo Santos hit the right upright from 53. Santos came back out at 1:34 and made a 58-yarder, which put 51 on the board and beat the Under 50.5 by half a point. Andy Borregales' 47-yarder at 0:37 left New England three points short of a push, and Caleb Williams took a knee.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
Steelers 16, Saints 10
The Steelers −3.5 was covering by 2.5 when Daniel Carlson lined up a 52-yarder at 9:32 of the fourth that would have flipped it, and he pushed it wide right. Chris Boswell's 37-yarder at 1:04 came off the board on a Saints offside flag, and Aaron Rodgers knelt it out. The Over 44.5 never had a pulse.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
49ers 20, Falcons 29
The 49ers −3.5 was still breathing at 26-20 after Brock Purdy's 1-yard touchdown pass to Kyle Juszczyk at 5:05. Then Kendal Daniels intercepted Purdy at 2:42, and Nick Folk's 31-yarder made it 29-20. The Under 50.5 owes two kickers a fruit basket. Folk hit the upright on one extra point and Eddy Pineiro pushed another wide left, and the game finished one and a half points under. Follow The Money's only call of the week was the Over, and those two kicks sank it.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side.
Browns 27, Titans 24
The Under 38.5 was dead by 4:34 of the fourth, when Deshaun Watson ran 9 yards for a touchdown. Tony Pollard's 1-yard touchdown with 58 seconds left tied it 24-24 and had four pickers covering the Titans +1.5. With three seconds left, Tennessee jumped offside on the field goal try, and Andre Szmyt hit from 32 on the final play. Letdown Watch, alone on the Browns −1.5, has not stopped talking about it.
Called it: Next Man Up and In The Trenches on the Over 38.5, cleared it by 12.5 points. Letdown Watch on the Browns −1.5, covered by 1.5 points.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
Colts 10, Vikings 16
The Colts +6.5 was hanging on at 13-10 with 2:02 left when Kyler Murray hit Jordan Addison for 34 yards down to the Indianapolis 2, and a holding flag on Minnesota wiped it out. The Vikings settled for Will Reichard's 52-yarder, won by six, and the Colts +6.5 cashed by half a point. That holding flag was worth a whole week to four pickers. The Over 41.5 never got close, and In The Trenches, alone on the Under, cashed it by 15.5.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
Dolphins 28, Jets 25
Sanders' 33-yard field goal at 8:57 of the fourth made it 21-17 and left the Over 39.5 a point and a half short. Malik Willis hit Caleb Douglas for a 63-yard touchdown at 4:44, which took the total from 38 to 45 in one play and buried the Jets −4.5. The Jets' late touchdown and two-point try made it 28-25, and only the score looked close.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
Buccaneers 43, Panthers 13
The Panthers −3.5 was finished in the second quarter. Calijah Kancey returned a fumble 32 yards for a touchdown, Zyon McCollum returned a blocked extra point for two points, and it was 33-6 at the half. Sean Tucker's 46-yard touchdown run at 10:21 of the fourth cashed the Over 44.5. Next Man Up, alone on the Buccaneers +3.5, cashed by 33.5.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
Bengals 35, Ravens 13
This was the Lock It Up game. Next Man Up, Letdown Watch and In The Trenches left the Bengals +2.5 for the Ravens +3, and four pickers left the Under 51 for the Over 46.5. Baltimore led 13-0 late in the first half. Then Joe Burrow threw touchdowns to Mike Gesicki, Tee Higgins and Ja'Marr Chase. At 7:25 of the fourth Demetrius Knight Jr. intercepted Tyler Huntley, and Drew Sample's 16-yard touchdown at 6:21 made it 48 points, over the 46.5 and under the 51, and nobody scored again. Both totals cashed. Neither Baltimore ticket came close.
Lock It Up check: The Formula, Next Man Up, Letdown Watch and In The Trenches moved off the Under 51 to the Over 46.5, and the Under 51 would have stayed under by 3 points. Next Man Up, Letdown Watch and In The Trenches moved off the Bengals +2.5 to the Ravens +3, and the Bengals +2.5 would have covered by 24.5 points.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
Giants 27, Texans 21
The Giants +9.5 never needed the points. Cam Skattebo's 16-yard touchdown run at 8:55 of the fourth put New York up 21-14, and C.J. Stroud tied it with 52 seconds left. Regulation ended 21-21, one point short of the Over 43, so In The Trenches was one overtime stop from cashing the Under. Devin Singletary's 30-yard touchdown run in overtime ended that. The Formula's Lock It Up move to the Giants +10.5 turned a loser into a winner by 16.5.
Lock It Up check: The Formula moved off the Texans −9.5 to the Giants +10.5, and the Texans −9.5 would have missed by 15.5 points.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
Broncos 30, Cardinals 16
The Cardinals +4.5 needed a stop late in the third, and J.K. Dobbins' 1-yard touchdown on the last play of the quarter survived a replay review and put Denver up 27-13. Wil Lutz's 31-yarder made it 30-13 and left the Over 43.5 half a point short. Then Chad Ryland made a 41-yarder on 4th-and-17 at 6:21. In The Trenches lost the Under to a field goal on 4th-and-17. Of all the ways.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
Packers 17, Lions 20
DJ Wonnum blocked Trey Smack's 35-yarder with the score tied 17-17 at 3:25. That kick would have cashed the Packers +3. Jared Goff knelt at the Green Bay 4, and Jake Bates kicked a 22-yarder on the final play. Three points, refunds all around. The Under 53.5 was never in danger.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
Rams 35, Raiders 21
The Raiders cut it to 28-18 at 13:12 of the fourth, and a failed two-point try left the Over 47.5 a point and a half short. Blake Corum's 4-yard touchdown at 6:34 settled both tickets. Next Man Up, Letdown Watch and In The Trenches got their switch right, from the Raiders +4.5 to the Rams −3.5. Next Man Up also moved from the Over 47.5 to the Under 48.5, and it will be hearing about that for a while.
Lock It Up check: Next Man Up, Letdown Watch and In The Trenches moved off the Raiders +4.5 to the Rams −3.5, and the Raiders +4.5 would have missed by 9.5 points. Next Man Up moved off the Over 47.5 to the Under 48.5, and the Over 47.5 would have cleared it by 8.5 points.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.
Chiefs 3, Seahawks 20
The Chiefs +2.5 needed Kansas City inside two, and it was 13-3 when Harrison Butker missed a 45-yarder wide right at 8:38 of the fourth. Emanuel Wilson's 21-yard touchdown run at 3:47 finished it. Letdown Watch was alone on the Seahawks −2.5, In The Trenches was alone on the Under 42.5, and both won by double digits.
Called it: Letdown Watch on the Seahawks −2.5, covered by 14.5 points. In The Trenches on the Under 42.5, stayed under by 19.5 points.
No pick: Follow The Money on the side or the total.