Three and a half points looks about as big to me as the 24-foot Fiona nutcracker the Cincinnati Zoo just stood at its front gate. My Steelers vs Bengals prediction for Week 10 is the Pittsburgh Steelers +3.5 against the spread and the Under 49.5 on Sunday night, in a game between two 6-2 division rivals.
Cincinnati is −3.5 at home at DraftKings as of Nov 15, 6:14 AM ET, and the total is 49.5, up a point from the 48.5 in Tuesday's Action Network consensus.
The Formula: Net ratings Cincinnati Bengals −1.2, Pittsburgh Steelers −4.8 (nflverse play-by-play, Nov 10, 2026).
Start with the schedule. Pittsburgh had last week off after beating Cleveland 27-6, so Mike McCarthy and Aaron Rodgers get two weeks to prepare. Cincinnati is on normal rest after a 34-17 win over Atlanta in Madrid. In a division game this tight, the extra week is worth something.
Then the trenches. The Steelers gain 5.2 yards a carry, and the Bengals allow 5.2. Jaylen Warren should find room. Going the other way, Cincinnati runs for 4.0 against a Pittsburgh defense that allows 3.8, so Joe Burrow and Ja'Marr Chase have to carry it through the air into T.J. Watt and Cam Heyward. The Steelers have 26 sacks.
Rodgers and Burrow both started their last games. The league's Week 10 injury report hadn't posted when I checked Tuesday morning.
The Under comes from Pittsburgh's profile. The Steelers have scored 180 and allowed only 144 in eight games. Their games don't get loose. Cincinnati has scored 240 and allowed 175, so the Bengals bring the points, but a Pittsburgh team that runs well and rushes the passer can shorten this game. My total is 47, two and a half under the number.
Sunday morning update: as of Nov 15, 6:14 AM ET, DraftKings has Bengals −3.5, total 49.5. This preview was written against Bengals −3.5, total 48.5, so the spread is unchanged and the total rose from 48.5 to 49.5. The Cover Writer stays on Steelers +3.5 with Bengals 25, Steelers 22, because Bengals by 3 stays inside the 3.5. The Under holds, now 49.5, with 47 points.
Follow The Money, which follows the Action Network consensus: the consensus spread has not moved from Bengals −3.5, and the consensus total opened 48.5 and is 49.5 now, so it has no side pick (no move of a full point) and moves to the Over 49.5. The Formula: Bengals 26, Steelers 20 on net ratings. It stays on Bengals −3.5 (Bengals by 6 clears the 3.5) and stays on the Under, now 49.5 (46 points). Next Man Up: Bengals 24, Steelers 23 on who's playing. It stays on Steelers +3.5 (Bengals by 1 stays inside the 3.5) and stays on the Under, now 49.5 (47 points). Letdown Watch: Bengals 24, Steelers 23 on rest and travel. It stays on Steelers +3.5 (Bengals by 1 stays inside the 3.5) and stays on the Under, now 49.5 (47 points). In The Trenches: Bengals 26, Steelers 23 on the line of scrimmage. It stays on Steelers +3.5 (Bengals by 3 stays inside the 3.5) and moves from the Over 48.5 to the Under 49.5 (49 points).
My card says Cincinnati Bengals 25, Pittsburgh Steelers 22. That's a three-point Bengals win, inside the 3.5, and it's a field goal finish, which is about what two teams this even should produce. Cincinnati is 2-1 at Paycor Stadium. Pittsburgh is 2-2 on the road. Nothing about either number says blowout.
Fiona's Festival of Lights opens Nov. 19. Sunday night, Cincinnati gets the win and Pittsburgh gets the hook.
Bengals 25, Steelers 22. Steelers cover the 3.5. Under 49.5.