Indiana's favorite underdog movie turns forty, and Hoosiers gets a Sunday screening with a Q and A at the Palladium in Carmel while the Colts are playing. My Dolphins vs Colts prediction doesn't need a miracle: the pick is Colts 24, Dolphins 20, which takes Miami +4.5 for my spread vote after the line moved from Colts −2.5, and sends the over/under to the Over at 37.5.
Two bad teams, and I'm not dressing it up. Miami is 1-7 and winless at home, with 126 points scored and 200 allowed. Indianapolis is 2-7 and has lost five straight, with 184 scored and 249 allowed. The question isn't who's good. It's who's less broken in this building on this afternoon.
The Formula: Net ratings Indianapolis Colts −8.9, Miami Dolphins −8.5 (nflverse play-by-play, Nov 10, 2026).
The Colts have the stronger offense and home field, and that's enough. They're 1-3 at home, not great, but Miami is 1-3 on the road, and its last game was a 19-9 loss in which it never reached the end zone against Detroit. The Colts have also won three straight in the series. A four-point Colts win falls a half-point short of the 4.5, which is why I'm taking Miami with the points, and that's the score I'm defending.
The risk is Daniel Jones. He's thrown ten interceptions against six touchdowns and has been picked off in eight of nine games, including four straight. That's why this isn't a bigger number, and it's why Miami can hang around. Kyle McCord makes his first NFL start now that Malik Willis is on injured reserve, and Miami needs its run game to keep him in manageable downs.
The Over is about the run defenses. Miami runs for 4.5 yards a carry, and Indianapolis allows 5.3, the worst number on either side of this matchup. The Colts run for 4.2 against a Dolphins defense that allows 4.2. Indianapolis has allowed 249 points in nine games, and Jones's turnovers hand out short fields. Colts 24, Dolphins 20 adds up to 44, six and a half clear of 37.5.
Sunday morning update: as of Nov 15, 6:14 AM ET, DraftKings has Colts −4.5, total 37.5. This preview was written against Colts −2.5, total 40.5, so the spread moved from Colts −2.5 to Colts −4.5 and the total dropped from 40.5 to 37.5. The Cover Writer now takes Dolphins +4.5 instead of Colts −2.5, with the same final, Colts 24, Dolphins 20. Colts by 4 was more than the old 2.5 and falls short of today's 4.5. The Over holds, now 37.5, with 44 points.
Follow The Money, which follows the Action Network consensus: the consensus spread opened Colts −2.5 and is Colts −4.5 now, and the consensus total opened 40.5 and is 37.5 now, so it moves to Colts −4.5 and moves to the Under 37.5. The Formula: Colts 23, Dolphins 22 on net ratings. It stays on Dolphins +4.5 (Colts by 1 stays inside the 4.5) and stays on the Over, now 37.5 (45 points). Next Man Up: Colts 25, Dolphins 19 on who's playing. It stays on Colts −4.5 (Colts by 6 clears the 4.5) and stays on the Over, now 37.5 (44 points). Letdown Watch: Colts 23, Dolphins 20 on rest and travel. It moves from Colts −2.5 to Dolphins +4.5 (Colts by 3 stays inside the 4.5) and stays on the Over, now 37.5 (43 points). In The Trenches: Colts 24, Dolphins 20 on the line of scrimmage. It moves from Colts −2.5 to Dolphins +4.5 (Colts by 4 stays inside the 4.5) and stays on the Over, now 37.5 (44 points).
Lou Ferraro will skip the movie for the game and say he planned it that way. Carla Ruiz will watch Hoosiers on the flight home and admit the ending works. Sunday's ending is smaller: the home team by four, with plenty of points.
Colts 24, Dolphins 20. Dolphins cover the 4.5. Over 37.5.