Buffalo 34, Miami (OH) 31 in overtime, and that one is going to sit in my stomach all week. We led by 15 with 12 minutes left at Yager Stadium. We wore the special Myaamia helmets and jerseys. We had the night set up. Then we handed it away.
There was plenty to like for three quarters. Caleb Heavner hit Braylon Isom for a 21-yard touchdown, Rodney Nelson ran one in from 10, and it was 14-3. Jermaine Agee blocked a Buffalo punt and we scored on it to open the second half. Toney Coleman Jr. intercepted Jason Wright at our own 1, and CJ Young grabbed another one minutes later. Scoop Smith ran it in from 6 at 12:01 of the fourth. 31-16. Lights out, right?
Wrong. Buffalo converted a fourth-and-6 and a fourth-and-1 on the next drive, Chance Morrow scored and added the two-point try, and it was 31-24. Then came the drive that will haunt me. Buffalo went 80 yards in 12 plays, and we helped with two interference flags, including one that put the ball at our 2. Wright ran it in at 1:35. 31-31.
Overtime was a mess. Buffalo kicked a 27-yarder. We ran three plays, then a false start on fourth down pushed Kellan McLaughlin back to 45, and the kick was no good. McLaughlin came in with eight straight field goals made and went 1 of 3 on the night, missing from 42 in the third quarter too.
Game ball: D'Shawntae Jones, 112 yards on 17 carries. Isom had 7 catches for 89 yards. Malcolm McCain made 11 tackles, and we didn't turn it over once. Goat: discipline. Thirteen penalties for 104 yards is how you lose a game you led by two scores. And Morrow caught 12 balls for 199 yards against us. Nobody had an answer.
Our three-game win streak is over, and according to our own series history this is Buffalo's first win in Oxford since Oct. 29, 2015. We're 5-4 and 3-2 in the MAC. Buffalo won the fourth quarter 15-7, and that tells you everything.
Next: Ohio comes to Yager Stadium on Tuesday, Nov. 10, 8 PM ET on ESPN2. Battle of the Bricks, and the Bobcats are 5-0 in the league. Clean it up, play all four quarters, and send them home mad.