Marshall vs Old Dominion prediction, pick against the spread and over/under: I'm on Old Dominion Monarchs +2.5 and Under 45.5 at DraftKings, with a final of Old Dominion Monarchs 25, Marshall Thundering Herd 20. It's Homecoming and the "Monarch Masquerade" at S.B. Ballard Stadium, costumes welcome and masks banned.
Marshall's defense is the weak spot on this field. The Herd allows 30.7 points a game, and even its wins have been tight: 28-26 over Middle Tennessee, 30-24 at Missouri State, 36-35 over Gardner-Webb and 20-13 over South Alabama. Old Dominion's defense allows 26.8 and has won ugly before, 10-3 at App State, where Javen Gibson made four tackles for loss. Give me the home team at Homecoming with points. My final has the Monarchs winning outright.
Winnie Pocklington, paper crown on, face painted blue, meets Mercy Holderby at the gate. "Hear ye! Javen Gibson has five sacks. Lucas Struck has 61 tackles. The court crowns a winner at halftime."
Mercy, in green scrubs under her Marshall jacket, isn't impressed. "Winnie, we beat you 48-24 last year. Caleb Clark-Glover has 51 tackles, and Xayvion Turner-Bradshaw has four touchdown catches. We Are."
The concern is the Old Dominion offense. It scores 15.5 points a game, it was shut out 26-0 at Louisiana Tech, and Jaxon Potter was the third different Monarch to lead the team in throws this season. Marshall has won eight of the nine meetings since 2016.
The Under is about ODU's scoring. The Monarchs scored 17 points or fewer in five of their eight games, and five of those eight finished below 45.5 combined points. Marshall's last game ended 20-13. My 25-20 adds up to 45.
For the record, Action Network's consensus line opened at Marshall −2.5 and is −3 as of Oct 28, 2026, 10:28 PM ET, and DraftKings has Marshall −2.5. Action Network's consensus total opened at 45.5 and is 45.5 as of Oct 27, 2026, 4:44 PM ET.
The room is with the Monarchs. The Formula has Old Dominion 25-23, likes Old Dominion +2.5 and is on the Over without backing it. Next Man Up has Old Dominion 25-18, likes Old Dominion +2.5 and is on the Under without backing it. Follow The Money has no pick. In The Trenches has no pick. Letdown Watch has no score this week.
Next Man Up: "Monarchs at Homecoming. Winnie, cue the trumpets."
The Formula: "Home team, short number, better defense."
Follow The Money: "No pick from me. Leave the mask in the car."
A Marshall defense that gives up yards in bunches, an Old Dominion defense that can win ugly and an ODU offense that keeps scores low. Winnie gets her coronation. Give me the Monarchs and the Under.
Old Dominion Monarchs 25, Marshall Thundering Herd 20. Old Dominion Monarchs cover the 2.5. Under 45.5.