Boca Raton lights the city Christmas tree at Mizner Park on Saturday night, and the South Florida vs Florida Atlantic pick has to be settled a few hours before the switch gets flipped. My USF vs FAU pick is South Florida Bulls −1.5 with the Under 65.5, and my final is South Florida Bulls 33, Florida Atlantic Owls 29, kickoff 2:30 PM ET at Flagler Credit Union Stadium, where the Owls close their home schedule in red.
Kaia Brightwater has been waiting all week to say it. "We are unbeaten in Paradise. Five home games, five wins. Caden Veltkamp has 3,086 yards and 29 touchdowns, Easton Messer has 1,033 receiving yards, and you want me to worry about a team that just gave up 52 to Memphis?"
Reina Valdés-Kowalski does not flinch. "We gave up 52 and still put up 41, and Luke Kromenhoek ran 30 times for 146 yards. Your defense allows 35.3 a game, Kaia. We beat you 48-13 last October. Bring your tree."
The market moved toward Tampa. DraftKings opened Florida Atlantic −1.5 with the total at 69.5, as shown in ESPN pickcenter, and it now sits at South Florida −1.5 and 65.5. That is a three-point swing across the zero, and I agree with it. USF allows 18.8 points a game, the best defense on this field by a lot. FAU allows 35.3. When Veltkamp has to throw 58 times, as he did in the 21-38 loss at Tulsa, the Owls stop being a home-run team and start being a long-afternoon team.
Kromenhoek is the quarterback to price. He has taken the most throws in each of the last three USF games, and he threw for 271 and three scores against Memphis without an interception. D.J. Crowther gives the Bulls 689 rushing yards and seven touchdowns, which matters against a defense that bleeds points.
My Under is the harder sell, because FAU games have gone 51-49 with Rice and 60-29 with UTSA. But the total already fell four points from the DraftKings open, and six of USF's ten games have finished with forty or fewer combined points. My 62 stays under the 65.5.
The room is split on the side and the total. The Formula has South Florida 29, Florida Atlantic 28, so it takes South Florida −1.5 and the Under 65.5. Next Man Up calls it a 34-34 tie and takes Florida Atlantic +1.5 with the Over. Letdown Watch has South Florida 34, Florida Atlantic 26, likes the Bulls −1.5 and likes the Under. In The Trenches has no side and no over/under call on this one. Follow The Money is still waiting on a consensus spread, so its side is pending, and it has no total pick.
Next Man Up: "A tie. I called a tie so I could watch you sweat both ways."
The Formula: "You called a tie because you couldn't pick a team. Letdown Watch and I will be at Mizner Park by 7:30, already warm."
Red Out in the afternoon, holiday lights at night. One of these fan bases gets to enjoy the tree.
South Florida Bulls 33, Florida Atlantic Owls 29. South Florida Bulls cover the 1.5. Under 65.5.