Iowa allows 11.7 points a game and has three shutouts, so the obvious play is a low score. I'm going the other way on the total in Champaign. The Iowa vs Illinois spread is Illinois Fighting Illini +7, the total is 42.5, and my pick is Illinois Fighting Illini +7 and Over 42.5.
DraftKings opened Iowa −5.5 and 43.5. The side has moved toward Iowa, and the total has come down a point. Both moves give me a better number than the opener.
Start with the seven points. Illinois is 6-4 and had won four straight before a 22-14 loss at UCLA on a Friday night. The Illini beat Oregon 21-10 and Nebraska 24-13 at home. Katin Houser has 2,131 passing yards and 18 touchdowns, and Collin Dixon has 72 catches for 946 yards and 13 touchdowns. Margery Vandermolen ran it through her slide rule: "One bad night in Pasadena. Three interceptions. It won't repeat."
Iowa is the better team. It's 8-2, ranked No. 15, and coming off wins of 30-0, 24-10 and 28-7. But the Hawkeyes' offense is modest. Hank Brown has 1,504 passing yards, ten touchdowns and four interceptions, and Iowa scored 16 against Iowa State, 20 at Michigan and 10 at Minnesota. Orrin Kalvelage says that's how Iowa likes it: "We win with defense and punting." That style keeps games close, and seven points is a lot to give against a home team that scores 27.0 a game.
Now the Over. My final is Iowa Hawkeyes 25, Illinois Fighting Illini 19, and those 44 combined points clear 42.5 by a point and a half. Illinois gets two touchdowns from Houser and Dixon, and Iowa's offense has scored 24 or more in each of its last three. It's tight, but the number has come down far enough.
Iowa wins by six, and Illinois covers the 7.
The room likes the points. The Formula likes Illinois +7 and likes the Over 42.5 at 25-21. Next Man Up likes Illinois +7 and likes the Under 42.5 at 22-18. Letdown Watch likes Iowa −7 at 27-16 and is Over 42.5. In The Trenches has the trenches split, so it has no side and no over/under call. Follow The Money is still waiting on a consensus spread, so its side is pending, and it has no total pick.
Next Man Up: "Forty points total. Iowa doesn't play Overs."
The Formula: "Dixon scores. Iowa scores. That's enough for 46."
Letdown Watch: "Illinois just lost in Pasadena. Senior Day won't fix that."
Bret Bielema played at Iowa, and he knows this kind of game better than anyone. His team keeps it within a touchdown.
Iowa Hawkeyes 25, Illinois Fighting Illini 19. Illinois Fighting Illini cover the 7. Over 42.5.