The two oldest universities in Ohio meet for the 103rd time on Tuesday night, and only one side leaves Oxford with a reason to pour something warm into a new mug. Ohio Bobcats vs Miami (OH) RedHawks is the Battle of the Bricks at Yager Stadium, and Penny Trautman and Cordelia Van Doren have been arguing about it since roughly 1804.
That's the year Ohio University was founded, and Penny brings it up before she even sits down. "Eighteen-oh-four. We're older. We were teaching people to read while Miami was still an idea."
"Eighteen-oh-nine," Cordelia answers. "Five years is nothing between friends. And a quiz for you, Penny: who won the very first one, in 1908?"
Penny knows. Everybody in both towns knows. Miami won it 5-0, back when a touchdown was worth five points, and Miami still leads the series 56-44 with 2 ties. Penny counters with the present, which is where she'd rather live. Ohio won the 2024 MAC title game over Miami 38-3 in Detroit and then won last year's meeting in Athens 24-20. Every Ohio win over Miami comes with a commemorative mug for the players and staff, and Penny treats that tradition like scripture.
"Two in a row," Penny says. "I'd like a third."
"You can have tea in one of the ones you've got," Cordelia says. "We'll keep the 100th anniversary game, thank you." Miami won that one at Yager in October of 2024, 30-20, and she keeps the score in her head like a phone number.
Oxford has a little music going before kickoff too. Over at Souers Recital Hall, there's an evening of American Latin music for oboe and piano at 7:30, half an hour before the RedHawks run out. Cordelia says she plans to hear the first piece and then walk briskly. Penny says she'll be in her seat early, wearing green, which in Oxford counts as a form of protest.
Now the football, and both of them shift in their seats.
Ohio is 7-2 and a perfect 5-0 in the MAC, first place in the conference. The Bobcats score 29.4 points a game and give up 21.7. Nick Poulos has taken the most throws in each of the last four games and has 978 yards with 7 touchdowns. Riley Neer is the go-to receiver, with 41 catches for 551 yards and 5 scores, and Dom Dorwart had 108 yards against Akron last week. Duncan Brune ran 10 times for 111 yards in that game. On defense, Michael Molnar is everywhere: 86 tackles and 6 sacks from the linebacker spot.
"Molnar is the whole hill," Penny says. "You go left, he's there. You go right, he's already there and waiting for you."
Miami is 5-4 and 3-2 in the league, and the RedHawks just lost a heartbreaker, 34-31 in overtime to Buffalo. Cordelia doesn't want to talk about it, then talks about it for five minutes. They score 27.4 a game. David McComb leads the team with 1,121 yards and only 1 interception, and Caleb Heavner has taken the most throws in each of the last five games. Maleek Huggins is the big-play receiver, with 473 yards on 27 catches. Rodney Nelson leads the ground game with 436 yards, and D'Shawntae Jones ran for 112 against Buffalo. Roosevelt Andrews III has 5.5 sacks up front, and Malcolm McCain has 70 tackles.
"We've played close all year," Cordelia says. "Twenty to nineteen at Massachusetts. Twenty-eight to twenty-seven at Central Michigan. Our people don't panic. Our people bring blankets."
The recent history is a seesaw. In the ten meetings since 2016, Ohio won six and Miami won four. Penny calls that a trend. Cordelia calls it a sample. They both call the 2021 game, a 35-33 Ohio win, the best one of the bunch.
"So how does it go?" Penny asks.
Here's how it goes. It's tight early, because this one is always tight early. Molnar gets to Heavner once in the first half and the Ohio fans at Yager get very loud. Poulos finds Neer for a big gain to put the Bobcats in front. Then Miami does what it's done all year and hangs around. Jones and Nelson grind out the third quarter. Huggins gets behind the defense once in the fourth. Andrews and McCain make the stop that matters with a few minutes left, and a late field goal sends Oxford home happy.
Cordelia rises, smooths her coat and announces that she'll be heading back toward the recital hall to see if the oboist is taking requests. Penny tucks her travel mug back into her bag, looks at Cordelia and says, "Fine. Next year, Peden Stadium."
My call: Miami (OH) RedHawks 27, Ohio Bobcats 24.