Buffalo vs Miami (OH) prediction, pick against the spread and over/under: I'm laying Miami (OH) RedHawks −6.5 and taking Over 45.5 at DraftKings, with my final at Miami (OH) RedHawks 29, Buffalo Bulls 22. Oxford spends Election Day with Party at the Polls under the Bell Tower on High Street, and by 8:00 PM ET the crowd walks past the Cradle of Coaches statues at the south gate of Yager Stadium for a game between two 5-3 teams.
Kendra Woolcott gives the weather report first, the way Western New York does. "Whatever the sky does in Oxford, it isn't lake effect," she says. "Messiah Burch ran 33 times for 184 yards and three scores against Bowling Green. He has 845 yards. We've won three in a row."
Cordelia Van Doren straightens her scarf beside the bronze Bo Schembechler. "So have we, Kendra. Massachusetts, Akron, Central Michigan. And a quiz for you: who won this game in 2025? We did, 37-20."
Here is why I lay it. Miami has won six of the nine meetings since 2016 in the CFBD file, and the RedHawks score 27.0 a game to Buffalo's 22.6. Buffalo has been living on the wire, winning 25-18 in overtime against Massachusetts and 31-28 over Robert Morris. Maleek Huggins has 431 receiving yards, and Roosevelt Andrews III has 4.5 sacks up front. My final has Miami by 7, just past the 6.5.
The quarterback question cuts both ways. Caleb Heavner has taken the most throws in each of Miami's last four games, and he threw 2 interceptions at Central Michigan. David McComb leads the team with 1,121 yards. I'm pricing Heavner, and it still comes out Miami.
For Buffalo, Jason Wright has 987 yards with 7 touchdowns and 4 interceptions, and Chance Morrow has 41 catches for 480 yards. If Burch controls the game, the Bulls hang around.
On the over/under, the open at DraftKings was 45.5, it dipped to 44.5, and it is back at 45.5. Miami allows 25.8 and Buffalo allows 25.4, and the 2025 meeting cleared this number by itself. My 29-22 adds up to 51.
The room splits on the side. Next Man Up has Miami 30-22, lays the −6.5 and likes the Over. The Formula has Miami 28-23, takes Buffalo +6.5 and likes the Over. In The Trenches likes Buffalo +6.5 and has no score this week. Follow The Money likes the Over 45.5, since the consensus total opened 44.5 and is 45.5 now. Letdown Watch has no score this week.
Next Man Up: "Eight points, Kendra. Bring a jacket anyway."
The Formula: "Five. Bulls inside the number, and both of us on the Over."
Cordelia adds a note to her coaching chart. Kendra tightens her hood and heads for the wings.
Miami (OH) RedHawks 29, Buffalo Bulls 22. Miami (OH) RedHawks cover the 6.5. Over 45.5.